Building an Accessory Dwelling Unit (ADU) is one of the smartest ways to create additional income from your property. Whether it’s a backyard cottage, a basement apartment, or a converted garage, ADUs appeal to homeowners because they transform underused space into a steady source of rental income. For many families in San Diego and across California, ADUs also make housing more flexible, allowing for multi-generational living while supporting long-term wealth building.

But there’s a reality most homeowners only discover after their unit is complete: being a landlord is a second job. Managing an ADU rental requires more than posting an ad online and collecting monthly rent. It involves marketing, screening tenants, drafting leases, handling maintenance calls, and staying compliant with local rental laws. For owners who envisioned passive income with little involvement, this reality can be a shock.

This is where the decision arises: should you manage your ADU yourself, or hire a property manager to oversee it? Both options are valid, but they serve very different lifestyles and investment strategies. To make the best choice, it helps to understand what managing an ADU really looks like on a day-to-day basis, why many homeowners grow frustrated with self-management, and how professional ADU property management can change the equation.

The Appeal of Self-Management: Why Many Owners Start as Their Own Landlord

When homeowners first build  an ADU, self-management often feels like the obvious choice. After all, the logic is simple: the less you spend on management fees, the more you keep as profit. For example, if your ADU rents for $2,000 a month and a property manager charges 10%, you’d keep $200 extra by handling it yourself. Over a year, that’s $2,400 saved — enough to cover part of your property taxes or make a few upgrades.

Beyond money, some homeowners value the control that comes with being directly involved. They like choosing tenants themselves, setting rules for their property, and being the first to know when something goes wrong. For others, managing an ADU feels like a natural extension of their homeownership — a way to stay hands-on with their investment and build confidence as new landlords.

Retirees, in particular, sometimes enjoy the involvement. They see it as a way to stay active, connect with tenants, and maintain oversight of their property. In this scenario, the ADU becomes not just a financial asset but also a project they take pride in.

But while the appeal of self-management is strong at the start, the responsibilities often grow heavier than expected.

The Reality Check: What Being an ADU Property Manager Really Involves

Being an ADU landlord is often described as “passive income,” but anyone who has managed tenants knows it’s far from passive. Here’s a closer look at the ongoing responsibilities that come with managing an ADU rental:

• Tenant Screening. Before tenants move in, landlords must advertise the property, run credit checks, verify employment, and call references. One poor choice can lead to late rent, property damage, or legal disputes.
• Lease Agreements. A handshake deal isn’t enough. ADU landlords must draft legally sound leases that comply with local laws, fair housing regulations, and city-specific ordinances. Without this, they risk costly legal challenges.
• Rent Collection. Tracking payments, following up on late rent, and enforcing penalties requires consistency and firmness — not always comfortable for homeowners renting on the same property.
• Maintenance and Repairs. Tenants call when the plumbing leaks, the power goes out, or the air conditioner breaks. Landlords must either fix the problem themselves or schedule reliable contractors quickly. Emergencies rarely happen at convenient times.
• Legal Compliance. Cities like San Diego have specific rules for ADU rentals, from occupancy limits to safety requirements. Staying compliant is critical to avoid fines or liability.

For homeowners with busy lives, these tasks add up quickly. A simple scenario illustrates the challenge: imagine a tenant calls at 9 p.m. on a Sunday because the water heater failed. As the landlord, you’re responsible for resolving it, no matter how inconvenient. Now imagine balancing this with a full-time career, family responsibilities, or managing a property hundreds of miles away.

The Emotional Toll of Tenant Management

Beyond logistics, managing tenants carries an emotional burden many homeowners don’t anticipate. Collecting late rent from someone you see in the driveway or confronting tenants about noise complaints can feel uncomfortable and stressful. Unlike managing a detached rental property, ADUs often place tenants in close proximity — sometimes sharing walls, driveways, or outdoor space with the homeowner.

This closeness can blur boundaries. Landlords may feel pressure to overlook small issues, while tenants may feel entitled to ask for favors. Over time, these dynamics can strain relationships and reduce the sense of privacy that ADUs were meant to preserve.

It’s not uncommon for homeowners who self-manage to admit that the stress of tenant interactions outweighs the financial savings. The extra income starts to feel less like passive revenue and more like compensation for constant stress.

Why Many Homeowners Turn to Property Management

After a few months or years of managing tenants, many ADU owners reach the same conclusion: their time and peace of mind are worth more than the management fees. Professional property managers specialize in handling exactly the challenges that overwhelm homeowners.

They provide:

• Tenant screening expertise. Professional managers use proven systems to vet tenants, reducing the risk of late rent or property damage.
• Legal compliance. Managers stay current on rental laws and ensure leases, deposits, and procedures are compliant.
• 24/7 maintenance support. Instead of homeowners fielding late-night calls, managers coordinate repairs with trusted vendors.
• Rent collection systems. Automated systems ensure payments are tracked, late fees enforced, and financial records maintained.

For homeowners who value true passive income, these services transform an ADU from a part-time job into a stable, low-stress investment.

Who Benefits Most from Professional ADU Property Management?

Not every homeowner needs a property manager, but for certain situations, it’s the smartest move:

• Busy professionals. Those with demanding careers often lack the time or energy to handle tenant needs.
• Remote owners. Homeowners who live far from their ADU cannot practically respond to maintenance or emergencies.
• Multi-generational families. Those using an ADU for both family and rentals may prefer a manager to maintain boundaries.
• Owners seeking scalability. If you plan to build multiple ADUs or expand into more rental properties, management is essential.

By recognizing these scenarios, homeowners can see when DIY management makes sense and when professional help is the better choice.

A Financial Perspective: The Hidden Cost of DIY Becoming an ADU Landlord

While property management fees range from 8–12% of monthly rent, many homeowners underestimate the hidden costs of self-management. These include:

• Vacancies. Poor tenant screening can lead to evictions or short leases, leaving units empty for weeks or months.
• Maintenance mistakes. DIY repairs often fail, requiring costly rework.
• Legal risks. Noncompliance with rental laws can result in fines or lawsuits.
• Time value. Hours spent managing tenants are hours lost to careers, families, or personal interests.

For example, saving $200 a month by avoiding management fees might seem like a win, but if you lose $2,000 annually from longer vacancies or legal missteps, the savings evaporate. In this way, property management often pays for itself.

Why This Decision Matters for Your Long-Term Goals

Ultimately, the choice between self-managing and hiring a property manager is less about today and more about tomorrow. Do you want your ADU to provide extra income with minimal involvement, or do you want to be hands-on and maximize every dollar? Neither is wrong — but the right choice depends on your lifestyle, your tolerance for stress, and your financial goals.

Self-Managing an ADU: Pros & Cons

When you first build an Accessory Dwelling Unit (ADU), the dream of passive income feels within reach. The idea is straightforward: rent the space, collect monthly checks, and enjoy the financial benefits of turning unused square footage into steady revenue. For many homeowners, the logical first step is to self-manage. Why pay a property manager when you can handle everything yourself and keep 100% of the rental income?

It’s an appealing thought, and for some homeowners, self-management works well. But for many, the role of “landlord” quickly reveals itself as a second job — one that demands time, organization, and a willingness to handle uncomfortable situations. In this section, we’ll unpack the pros and cons of managing an ADU rental yourself, highlighting what’s truly involved and helping you decide if it’s the right fit for your lifestyle.

The Appeal of Self-Management: Why Homeowners Choose It

The main reason homeowners self-manage is financial. Every dollar spent on property management fees feels like money left on the table. If your ADU rents for $2,000 per month and a management company charges 10%, that’s $200 a month — or $2,400 per year — you could save by handling things yourself. For many families, that’s a vacation, a new appliance, or a year’s worth of utility bills.

Control is another motivator. Homeowners who manage their own ADUs decide who lives in their unit, how repairs are handled, and how quickly issues are resolved. For those who view their ADU as part of their property rather than a detached investment, this control provides peace of mind.

Finally, some owners enjoy the involvement. Retirees often like meeting new tenants and staying active with small repairs. Parents may view the rental as an opportunity to teach their adult children about responsibility and income. In these scenarios, self-management isn’t just about money — it’s about staying connected to the property and the people living in it.

The Financial Benefit: Keeping More of Your Rental Income

For homeowners drawn to maximizing profit, the financial benefit of self-management is undeniable. Property management fees, typically between 8% and 12% of monthly rent, add up quickly. On a $2,000 rental, that’s $160–$240 per month. Over five years, the savings could reach $10,000–$15,000 — enough to fund another renovation project or pay down a mortgage faster.

Avoiding leasing fees adds even more savings. Many property managers charge the equivalent of one month’s rent to place a new tenant, which could mean an extra $2,000 expense every year or two. By advertising and screening tenants yourself, you eliminate this cost.

These numbers can be compelling. For homeowners focused on maximizing ROI, the ability to pocket these savings makes self-management feel like the most strategic choice. But the financial benefit is only one side of the equation. What you save in dollars, you may pay in time and stress.

The Responsibilities of an ADU Landlord

Self-management means stepping into the full role of a landlord, with all the responsibilities that come with it. Many homeowners underestimate the scope of these tasks until they’re in the middle of them.

• Marketing the rental. You’ll need to photograph the ADU, write listings, post them on platforms, and respond to inquiries. In competitive rental markets, speed and presentation make the difference between weeks of vacancy and a signed lease.
• Tenant screening. Running credit checks, verifying employment, calling references, and interviewing applicants are all part of finding the right tenant. One poor decision can lead to months of late rent or even eviction.
• Lease creation. You’ll need a legally sound lease that complies with local ordinances, covers deposit rules, and protects you against liability. Generic forms downloaded online often fail to meet local requirements.
• Rent collection. From setting up payment systems to enforcing late fees, consistent rent collection is a core responsibility. It requires firmness and professionalism, especially if tenants fall behind.
• Maintenance and repairs. Tenants call when the toilet clogs, the oven breaks, or the roof leaks. Whether you fix issues yourself or hire contractors, you’re the first point of contact — and emergencies don’t follow business hours.
• Legal compliance. ADUs are subject to city-specific regulations. Staying compliant with occupancy limits, inspection requirements, and tenant rights laws is essential to avoid fines or lawsuits.

Each of these responsibilities requires time, organization, and a willingness to be proactive. For some homeowners, the challenge feels manageable. For others, it becomes an ongoing burden that outweighs the financial savings.

The Personal Side: Building Tenant Relationships

One of the overlooked aspects of self-management is the relationship dynamic between landlord and tenant. When you manage the ADU yourself, you’re not just a property owner — you’re a neighbor, too.

This closeness can create positives. Direct relationships sometimes foster loyalty, with tenants staying longer because they feel personally connected to the homeowner. Good communication can also create smoother interactions when issues arise.

But the proximity can also create tension. Enforcing rules or chasing late rent feels more uncomfortable when the tenant lives a few feet away. Small annoyances — like parking habits or noise levels — can escalate because of the shared property line. Homeowners who dislike confrontation may find this emotional strain harder than the financial savings are worth.

The Hidden Costs of Self-Management

While saving on management fees is attractive, self-management carries hidden costs that reduce its financial advantage.

• Vacancies. If your marketing is slow or your screening isn’t thorough, you risk longer vacancy periods. Even one extra month of vacancy per year at $2,000 rent wipes out $2,000 in savings.
• Turnover. Poor tenant screening may result in frequent turnover, which means more advertising, more showings, and more stress.
• Maintenance errors. Attempting DIY fixes to save money can backfire if repairs fail and require professional rework.
• Time value. Every hour spent answering calls, scheduling repairs, or chasing rent is time away from your career, family, or personal pursuits.

When these hidden costs are factored in, the savings from self-management often shrink — and in some cases, disappear entirely.

When Self-Management Makes Sense

Despite the challenges, self-management can be the right choice in certain scenarios. If your ADU is on the same property as your primary residence, responding to maintenance issues is simpler. If you have the time and enjoy hands-on involvement, being a landlord may feel rewarding.

Self-management also makes sense for homeowners who are detail-oriented, organized, and comfortable with confrontation. These qualities make tenant screening smoother and reduce the likelihood of disputes.

For example, a homeowner who lives in their primary residence full-time, enjoys home maintenance projects, and wants maximum profit from their ADU may thrive as a self-managing property owner. In this case, the responsibilities feel manageable and the savings meaningful.

When Self-Management Becomes a Strain

On the other hand, self-management can quickly become unsustainable for homeowners with demanding jobs, frequent travel, or little interest in property management. The stress of handling late-night maintenance calls, enforcing lease terms, and staying compliant with local laws may outweigh the financial savings.

For multi-generational families, the dynamic can be even more complicated. Balancing family needs with tenant management in the same space often leads to blurred boundaries and stress. For these homeowners, professional management may provide the privacy and separation they value.

The Decision in Context: Lifestyle and Long-Term Goals

The choice to self-manage isn’t just about saving money — it’s about lifestyle alignment. If you view your newly built ADU as a long-term rental investment, the effort required may not fit your vision of passive income. But if you enjoy involvement, have the time, and want to maximize every dollar, self-management could be a smart strategy.

It’s also worth considering how your goals might change over time. A younger homeowner might enjoy the involvement today, but as their career or family responsibilities grow, the stress may become less tolerable. Conversely, a retiree may find self-management enjoyable now but prefer to outsource later to reduce stress.

Bridging Forward: Weighing Against Professional Management

Understanding the pros and cons of self-management sets the stage for the next decision: should you continue handling everything yourself, or transition to professional ADU property management? By comparing your current experience with the services managers provide, you can determine which approach better supports your long-term goals.

Hiring a Property Manager: Pros & Cons

For many homeowners, the dream of ADU rental income comes with a sharp reality check: being a landlord isn’t always simple. Tenant calls come at inconvenient times, leases require careful attention, and local regulations shift faster than most people can keep up with. At some point, many owners begin asking themselves whether it might be worth paying a professional to take over.

This is where ADU property management comes in. By outsourcing the day-to-day responsibilities to a property manager, you transform your ADU rental into something closer to true passive income. But this convenience comes at a cost, both financially and in terms of control. To help you decide if hiring a property manager is the right move for you, let’s break down the pros and cons of hiring a professional property manager in detail.

The Core Appeal of Professional Management

The biggest draw of professional ADU property management is the promise of peace of mind. A skilled property manager assumes the responsibilities that overwhelm most homeowners: screening tenants, collecting rent, coordinating repairs, and ensuring compliance with housing laws. Instead of your phone buzzing with a maintenance emergency at midnight, the call goes to someone else.

This level of support allows homeowners to step back and truly enjoy the benefits of rental income. For those with demanding careers, family commitments, or properties located far from their primary residence, management isn’t just a convenience — it’s often the only way to make the rental viable long-term.

Another key appeal is expertise. Property managers live and breathe the rental market. They understand what tenants look for, what legal requirements apply, and how to keep an ADU consistently occupied. For many homeowners, this expertise directly translates into higher returns and fewer mistakes.

The Pros of Hiring a Property Manager

1. True Passive Income

One of the most compelling benefits of hiring a property manager is that it turns your ADU into a nearly hands-off investment. Once the lease is signed, your manager handles the rest: rent collection, maintenance requests, inspections, and tenant communication.

For busy professionals, this is invaluable. Instead of spending weekends dealing with tenant issues, you can focus on your career, your family, or simply enjoying the lifestyle that ADU income supports. Retirees benefit as well — rather than stressing over repairs or legal forms, they can enjoy their property as a low-effort investment.

The psychological relief of not having to manage tenants directly is often worth the fees alone. Many homeowners find that the “mental bandwidth” they regain outweighs the cost of professional management.

2. Professional Tenant Screening

Tenant selection (and designing your space to attract the right tenant) is one of the most critical aspects of managing an ADU rental. A great tenant pays on time, cares for the property, and stays long-term. A poor tenant can create months of stress, late payments, and even property damage.

Property managers bring established screening systems to the table. They run credit and background checks, verify employment, and call references. They also understand how to evaluate applicants fairly and legally, avoiding any violations of fair housing laws.

For homeowners who don’t have experience with screening, this expertise prevents costly mistakes. The difference between a great tenant and a poor one can be thousands of dollars per year, making screening one of the most valuable services a manager provides.

3. Legal and Regulatory Compliance

Rental laws can be complex, especially in cities like San Diego where ADU regulations evolve frequently. From rent control rules to safety requirements, landlords are expected to stay informed and compliant at all times. Missing even one detail can result in fines or legal disputes.

Property managers stay updated on these requirements and ensure leases, deposits, and eviction processes follow the law. They also manage inspections and certifications when required. This reduces the homeowner’s liability and ensures the rental operates smoothly.

For many owners, this legal expertise is worth the fee alone. Instead of spending hours researching regulations, you can trust that your manager is keeping your rental compliant.

4. Efficient Maintenance and Repairs

Another major advantage is access to a network of reliable contractors. Property managers typically have long-standing relationships with plumbers, electricians, and handymen. This means faster response times, better pricing, and consistent quality.

For homeowners, this eliminates the stress of scrambling to find help when something breaks. It also reduces the risk of hiring unqualified contractors or attempting DIY fixes that may not last. By coordinating everything from small repairs to major upgrades, property managers keep your ADU in top condition.

This efficiency often improves tenant satisfaction as well. Tenants are far more likely to renew their lease when issues are handled quickly and professionally. Fewer turnovers mean more consistent income for you.

5. Higher Occupancy and Rental Income

Property managers understand how to market rentals effectively. They know which listing platforms to use, how to photograph properties, and how to write descriptions that attract quality tenants. This often translates into shorter vacancy periods and higher rents.

For ADU owners, this can offset the cost of management fees. For example, if a property manager reduces vacancy by one month per year on a $2,000 rental, that’s $2,000 in additional income — often enough to cover their fee for the entire year.

In this way, professional management doesn’t just save you time — it can actually improve your bottom line.

The Cons of Hiring a Property Manager

While the advantages are clear, hiring a property manager isn’t the right fit for everyone. There are trade-offs to consider before making the decision.

1. Management Fees Reduce Profit

The most obvious downside is cost. Most property managers charge between 8% and 12% of monthly rent, plus leasing fees when new tenants are placed. On a $2,000 rental, that means $160–$240 per month, plus additional charges.

For homeowners relying on every dollar of rental income, this can feel like a significant loss. Over the course of several years, fees add up. If your ADU is already cash-flowing at a thin margin, management fees may cut too deeply into profits.

This is why some homeowners decide to self-manage until they reach a point where time savings outweigh the cost. For others, it’s worth it immediately.

2. Less Direct Control

Hiring a property manager means you give up some control. You won’t be the one choosing tenants directly, scheduling repairs, or negotiating leases. While most managers keep owners informed, the day-to-day decisions are often theirs.

For homeowners who like to be hands-on, this can feel frustrating. You may not always agree with the manager’s choices, from the tenant they recommend to the contractor they hire for repairs.

That said, many property managers are open to creating clear communication protocols. Owners who want more involvement can set boundaries to ensure they remain in the loop.

3. Quality Varies Between Managers

Not all property management companies deliver the same level of service. Some are highly responsive and detail-oriented, while others are slow to respond or inattentive. Choosing the wrong manager can create new headaches rather than solving old ones.

This is why vetting is critical. Ask for references, read reviews, and interview managers carefully before hiring. Look for experience specifically with ADU rentals, since they often involve unique challenges compared to traditional properties.

A strong manager can make your rental experience effortless. A weak one can drain profits and damage tenant relationships.

4. Potential for Misaligned Priorities

While property managers work for you, their priorities may not always perfectly align with yours. For example, a manager may recommend lowering rent to fill a vacancy quickly, while you’d prefer to wait for a tenant willing to pay more.

This doesn’t mean property managers act against your interests, but it does highlight the importance of clear communication. Establishing your goals upfront ensures the manager works within your parameters.

Bridging the Pros and Cons

Deciding whether to hire a property manager isn’t about finding a “perfect” option — it’s about identifying what matters most to you. If you value maximum profit and control, the cons may outweigh the benefits. If you value time, peace of mind, and professional support, the pros may make management fees feel like a small price to pay.

What’s important is understanding how these trade-offs align with your long-term goals. Are you looking for a truly passive investment, or are you comfortable treating your ADU as a side business? Answering this question will guide you toward the right choice.

Putting Professional Management Into Perspective

Hiring a property manager for your ADU can feel like a big decision, but it ultimately comes down to lifestyle alignment. For homeowners who want freedom from tenant issues, legal headaches, and maintenance calls, professional management delivers true peace of mind. For those who prioritize every dollar of profit and enjoy hands-on involvement, self-management may still make sense.

At Home Experts Construction, we’ve seen homeowners thrive with both approaches. What matters is that your choice reflects your goals — whether that’s maximum profit, maximum convenience, or a balance of both.

If you’re weighing the decision, the next step is to evaluate your own priorities honestly. Think about your time, your tolerance for stress, and the role you want your ADU to play in your life. From there, you can decide whether property management is an investment worth making.

Ready to begin the process of designing and building an ADU that attracts high paying tenants?

Maybe you are interested in learning how to finance an ADU so you don’t break the bank?

Either way – when the time is right, we would love to provide a free ADU consultation when the time is right!